The DePaulia

Filed under Opinions

Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Protestors chant during their march on March 3 from the downtown Los Angeles site where a homeless man was killed by officers. (Al Seib | Tribune News Service)

Protestors chant during their march on March 3 from the downtown Los Angeles site where a homeless man was killed by officers. (Al Seib | Tribune News Service)

The Guardian, a British newspaper, published a series of articles about a Chicago Police Department (CPD) facility known as Homan Square, painting the site as a “C.I.A.-style black site.” The story went viral and compelled some to attend a protest at the facility demanding its closure.

The CPD denied any wrongdoing and the story seemed to end with that. One thing that I noticed was the lack of comment made by a major Chicago news publication until days later. The Tribune published an article that essentially said the civil rights violations exposed in The Guardian’s article was already a widely known problem.

Richard Dvorak, a veteran criminal defense attorney, told the Tribune, “Everything that was described (in the Guardian story) was something that happens every day. I think it’s pretty systematic throughout the CPD.”

The article suggests that rather than a CPD-Guantanamo, Homan is a place where “improper detention and interrogation techniques” are the main problem. Homan Square is a story that generated a lot of attention, however, it is only a glimpse into the whole problem; Police abuse has a much wider scope than one facility.

In Los Angeles a few days ago, police publicly shot and killed a man on skid row. In the conflict created by the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) the man, not officially identified, was tased and shot five times after allegedly struggling over an                      officer’s weapon.

An onlooker videotaped the shooting as well as its aftermath. In the video, cries and shouts of anger are heard from other onlookers. Bystanders were both shocked and outraged after witnessing the killing of the man.  One arrest was made after a woman attempted to pick up a nightstick dropped by an officer. This is unfortunately not an uncommon scene today.

We have seen it many times. Onlookers cry for help. People push and yell. Police swarm to contain the crowd and subdue any who resist. Videos of police beatings and killings are posted to the web on a weekly basis.

According to a study by USA Today, a white police officer killing a black person is a bi-weekly occurrence. There are an average of 400 police involved killings each year. We hear some of the names of these people, but just as often their stories go untold.

Names like Kenneth Chamberlain, 68, Eric Garner, 43, Michael Brown, 18, Kimani Gray, 16 and Tamir Rice, 12, all made headlines and sparked outrage and controversy, and they all faded out of the spotlight, waiting for the next addition to the list of names. These, along with many others, represent the people shot and killed by police in situations that arguably did not require lethal force. While anger and harsh words are often quick to follow, they are almost quicker to fade away.

It may be fashionable to rant on Facebook about police oppression, but when the buzz dies down and normality resumes these names are forgotten by many. The crimes against them are allowed to pass into irrelevancy.

When Homan Square is no longer a hot topic, the police will carry on in their secret interrogation sites, more underprivileged men, women and children will be shot to death, and more killers will walk free on “temporary paid leave.”

Professor Allison Tirres of the DePaul College of Law pointed out a major flaw in the justice system. “The criminal justice system has a number of key structural inequities that disfavor the poor, and racism is unfortunately embedded at many levels within the system,” Tirres said. “In high-crime areas poor policing can amount to constant harassment, particularly of blacks and Latinos. 

As we saw from the Justice Department’s investigation into conditions in Ferguson, some local governments openly encourage their officers and judges to conduct stops, make arrests and give tickets as a way of making more money for the city or county.  Ferguson officials were also openly racist in internal communications.  Such behaviors, in addition to being unconstitutional, disproportionately burden those with fewer resources.

For a large number of people, calling the police is not an option. Risking the consequences that come with a swarm of police in an underprivileged area is too great to even consider dialing 911. The blatant racism and institutional abuses that are engrained in law enforcement make it clear that while police exist “to protect and serve” and act as peacekeepers, that only applies to those with the privilege of police protection.

1 Comment

One Response to “Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?”

  1. Matthew on March 9th, 2015 12:04 am

    It is extremely problematic that you would post an opinion post on something that you have not very much understanding of. You do not even stop to consider the fact that the whole Homan Square fiasco has been a complete fabrication of the Guardian and their ever terrible reporting.
    There is no CPD black site.
    There is a building that serves 4 purposes. (a) Evidence lock up, any time you are ever arrested anything you had on your body at the time will end up at Homan Square for you to pick up when you get out. (b) district lockup. Any crime that has been committed within the precinct of Homan square will be handled and processed there. (c) This is the location where the police chief and other ranking officials will host press conferences when ever there is a large bust or major break in a case. Quite the opposite of what you would want in a black site, no? (4) it is the undercover CPD headquarters. This is where all the under cover officers that risk their lives every day are based. Because of the dangerous nature of their jobs, they can not be seen by the public, nor can their cars, hence no access to the parking as some were reporting.
    Also, even though there have been personal accusations, there is no evidence of the lock ups that the Guardian claimed happened. Also, there has not been a law suite filed.
    The opinion section does not translate to the blind trust and no research section.

    [Reply]

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    How ‘America’s Dad’ fell from public grace

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Our obsession with killers continues to distort our ability to separate the murders from the mugshot

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Left on read

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Don’t call Israel an apartheid state

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Open letter to the DePaul Board of Trustees: Make your investment profile public

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Not a death sentence: Why we need to change the way we talk to cancer patients

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Kanye West’s pro-Trump views don’t add up

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Puff puff pass – in class?: How vapes are changing the futures of teenagers

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    Light-skinned Latinxs can be privileged, too

  • Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?

    Opinions

    The death of a smile: It’s time to stop forcing women to bear the weight of constant happiness

The Student News Site of DePaul University
Homan Square: An isolated case or systemic issue?