Coalition for Racial Justice forms in light of Calvente tenure denial
After DePaul professor Dr. Lisa Calvente shocked the student body with a May 29 mass email detailing her tenure denial at DePaul, student and alumni took matters into their own hands, starting a new group aimed at helping Calvente receive tenure and changing the culture at DePaul.
The Coalition for Racial Justice formed on June 2 in response to Calvente’s denial of tenure, which she claims was based on discrimination, racism and sexism.
The DePaulia investigated Calvente’s tenure denial. Read more here.
After reaching out over email to one another, students made a Facebook group to discuss how to proceed. That page led to a formal Zoom call that would be the start of a group that hopes to change the culture at DePaul for students and faculty to come.
Gabriel Charles Tyler, assistant director of communications at the Center for Community Investment, graduated from DePaul in 2014. He was a former student of Calvente’s and said he was dumbfounded by her denial.
“DePaul as a university says it has values and principles that it abides to, among those being a commitment to institutional diversity, equity and inclusion,” Tyler said. “But what is happening now to Dr. Calvente is educational malpractice and it shows that the university and its administration is not living up to the things they say are the foundation of the institution.”
On June 9, Tyler tweeted that members of the Coalition for Racial Justice are calling for DePaul to reverse their tenure decision. They sent a letter to President A. Gabriel Esteban June 9, and after receiving no reply, followed up June 10. Tyler said they still have not heard back.
Along with the letter, they sent the link to their statement.
“We, a coalition of DePaul University students and alumni, stand with Assistant Professor Lisa B.Y. Calvente, PhD and demand that the university’s administration reverse the denial of her tenure,” the statement reads.
The statement also says that DePaul is not a representation of Chicago — but it should be.
Lauren Gonzalez, a senior at DePaul, said the group has made demands to DePaul about “increasing transparency, having more student oversight and also having a faculty that reflects the diversity of the city.”
Tyler said Calvente had a “profound impact” on her students.
“The more students started speaking out — the more students started connecting — it became more and more apparent that her as a professor had an impact that went beyond just what she was doing in the classroom,” Tyler said. “She imparted knowledge to us, and the way that she challenged us as students and helped open our minds.”
Evangeline Semark, DePaul class of 2014 and lead communications specialist of corporate engagement at Northwestern University, is a former student who believes Calvente’s strong teaching ability is important for everyday life.
“The Coalition is a testament to what so many of us have learned within Dr. Calvente’s classrooms: that we – her current and former students – are agents for change who possess the critical knowledge and skills to question what is thought to be known and to engage in day-to-day acts of resistance,” Semark said.
Surdeep Singh Chauhan, a junior at DePaul, was a former student of Calvente’s and a founding member of the Coalition for Racial Justice. Chauhan felt that an explanation was needed for how DePaul allegedly manipulated student responses and used them against Calvente.
“Once we got the news, it was just a blow that a lot of us weren’t ready for,” he said. “We were now seeing that she had become a victim of the very same discrimination, bigotry, sexism and just racist practices at DePaul herself.”
Many students in the group spoke out against what they claim to be obvious differences in the treatment of faculty based on race, with some mentioning underlying tones of white supremacy within the culture at DePaul.
Tyler said removing Calvente and denying her tenure will result in the absence of courses that “examine Blackness and racism,” given her areas of expertise.
“Dr. Calvente is the only senior faculty member of color within the College of Communications at DePaul, as well as the only tenure line faculty member in the college that specializes in the Black diaspora, anti-Black and anti-Brown racism, and coloniality and decolonization,” Tyler said.
“I believe that with the tragic murder of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, that in real time, we are witnessing, kind of like the veil being pulled from America, and we’re really seeing how white supremacy has its roots in every institution in this country,” Chauhan said.
“As a coalition of DePaul students and alumni committed to racial justice, we need DePaul to name its legacy of upholding white supremacy and acknowledge the harm that its anti-Black racism has caused for generations of People of Color and especially Black, Brown and Indigenous students, alumni, staff and faculty,” Semark said.
The Coalition for Racial Justice has many long-term goals in the works and points out that this is only the start of the change they want to see.
Abigail Escatel, DePaul graduate student, said while long-term goals are pending, transparency and accountability from the administration will be key.
“It’s been really clear to us that there is a lack of transparency in terms of all the procedural violations that Calvente’s experienced, which are really personal to us,” Escatel said.
The Coalition said it intends to continue asking the university to make substantive changes.
“In our response to the administration, the Coalition focused on profound and meaningful change to current policies, practices, procedures and the academic program that we feel have played a key role in upholding white supremacy and perpetuating systemic racism within the College of Communication and at DePaul,” Semark said.
UPDATE 6/10/20: This story has been updated to indicate that a statement was sent by the Coalition to President A. Gabriel Esteban once yesterday and another time this morning.
Gonzalas • Jun 12, 2020 at 7:02 pm
Padill does not want to solve things. His battery of lawyers just want to fight and they like it. That is really all they have. They enjoy screwing decent pep[;e. It makes them look important. They support administrators who are just evil and like harming others. It gives them all job security. Frightening. Please do better. Do no evil any longer. Try to find understanding and love for others even if they are different from you. Students should not have to pay for this type of stuff through our tuition.
Pink Hair • Jun 12, 2020 at 3:31 pm
Come on now. There had to be alternatives. DePaul did not need to terminate Dr. Conviser’s contract to counsel student athletes. She had the guts to point out that a coach should not call female athletes “whores.” Leaders in the athletics department should have taken action but covered it up and blamed her. Not ok. DePaul could have let Dr. Conviser continue to counsel students or maybe paid for the remainder of her contract or at least some of it. Anything other than just telling this woman to get lost. With Dr. Calvente, something went wrong. Other academics even during appeal found that her tenure process was patently unfair. DePaul should have come up with other alternatives besides just telling this minority woman to get lost. Not ok. Like Dr. Conviser, Dr. Calvente had to stand up. DePaul always asks what must be done? Solve issues.
Avery • Jun 11, 2020 at 7:54 pm
It seems like DePaul could have achieved better results than what happened.
Ms. Insightful • Jun 11, 2020 at 2:44 pm
Dr. Esteban and Mr. Padill have lost their way. This may be because they have been in power too long. They have grown cold and complacent. They have not progressed with society. Whatever the reasoning, this behavior is disturbing and they must be held accountable for their corrupt actions.
Nothing much has changed since the 1960’s at DePaul. Instead of vicious dogs, DePaul uses vicious lawyers to crush anyone who calls for human rights.
I am a snowflake. I am clueless. My DePaul education, along with my Obama phone, is paid with redistributed dollars that individuals who work hard each day earn, after which their incomes end up in my pocket so that I can go to Starbucks, have my navel pierced, dye my hair pink and receive crumbs on paper plates beneath my basement door. Please feel free to call me Gregor Samsa but the last time I checked, I, was a girl, at least in the same respect that Chelsea Manning was. Or is. I get so confused because I have missed six Gender Inequality classes where I would have learned this by Professor I.M Klueiss who has tried, for the past 5 years to get tenure but has been denied each time. Of course this has nothing to do with the fact that her student reviews are poor and she believes that the earth is flat and those that say it is not are repressed men or women, both or neither, who failed to resolve their Electra complexes. DePaul is really such a terrible place. I am progressing but society is not. All these stodgy white men that make all the rules and look at me as if I am Kendra Lust at a Miami nightclub, it is disgusting. These men have overactive id complex in service of ther egos. I learned that at Joliet Junior College, where i went before I entered DePaul. Speaking of vicious dogs, there are none at DePaul. I sure wish, however, that they had some therapy dogs because my Zoloft prescription is now empty and cannot be refilled. It sucks that the United States government stopped paying for my SSRIs but it is probably for the best, because I find that large, fast moving locomotives look like pretty, soft and puffy nimbus clouds when I forget to do the math and take 4 a day instead of, say, the 20 mg. I SHOULD be swallowing. Oh, and the vicious lawyers about which I am now complaining? One of them, a Cardoza Law graduate, acutally, will become my best friend when I get out of DePaul and begin working at Aldi’s as a bagger and that big mean stockboy (correction, person, binary gender/unknown) puts his hand on my back and I sue him for loss of consortium, pain and suffering and other misdeeds that preclude me, day two, from returning to this career opportunity of a lifetime. I am the future. I am DePaul. The world is in trouble… I am DePaul.
Avery • Jun 10, 2020 at 7:38 pm
DePaul is like a racist and sexist establishment in the 1960’s. Back then, the establishment used vicious dogs to terrify people into submission. Today, Dr. Esteban and DePaul’s attorney Mr. Padill use vicious lawyers to terrify people into submission.
Two courageous DePaul women are standing up to Dr. Esteban and Mr. Padill. Their names are Dr. Jenny Conviser and Dr. Lisa Calvente. They have both filed lawsuits.
Dr. Jenny Conviser had a four year contract to counsel DePaul students. She reported that an athletic coach was calling young female athletes “whores.” The female students are human beings and should not be sexualized by an adult that they trust. She also encouraged a student to report that they had witnessed the coach punching a female employee in the face.
Instead of thanking Dr. Conviser, DePaul terminated Dr. Conviser’s four year contract three years early. It retaliated against her for enforcing Title IX to protect students.
Assistant directors in the athletic department hid what was happening according to Dr. Conviser. Rather than beginning an investigation, they publicly criticized Dr. Conviser and accused her of things she did not do (this is called gaslighting). DePaul promoted those who helped terminate her. One of these individuals was promoted to the director of gender equity position that oversees Title IX. This is ironic and heart breaking.
Another example of this disturbing behavior is what happened to Dr. Lisa Calvente. She has also filed a lawsuit. Dr. Calvente called upon her students to consider race issues in our country. Especially considering recent events, such conversations are necessary for students to have. Rather than appreciating the behavior, DePaul manipulated data to make her look bad (gaslighting). According to Dr. Calvente, the school told her that their students are not as smart as Northwestern students and could not comprehend these issues. This is not true. DePaul made sure Dr. Calvente would not obtain tenure. They got rid of her too.
Dr. Esteban and Mr. Padill have and will viciously attack both women by unleashing their attorneys on the women who have attempted to reform the system and create justice. After both women were
“handled,” Dr. Esteban and Mr. Padill probably went to fancy DePaul parties and confidently gossiped about their accomplishments to crush the women.
Dr. Esteban and Mr. Padill have lost their way. This may be because they have been in power too long. They have grown cold and complacent. They have not progressed with society. Whatever the reasoning, this behavior is disturbing and they must be held accountable for their corrupt actions.
Nothing much has changed since the 1960’s at DePaul. Instead of vicious dogs, DePaul uses vicious lawyers to crush anyone who calls for human rights.
This is a call to donors, politicians, alumni, faculty, staff, the DePaulia, and most of all students. It is time to support Dr. Conviser and Dr. Calvente in any way you can. Protest. Use your voice. Use your power. Use your funds. Speak out. Change. Think through these issues and see the other side. Otherwise, you are perpetrators too. Silence is condonement.
#MeToo #BlackLivesMatter.